ARKBAR Open Forum

Task Force on Maintaining a Fair and Impartial Judiciary Appointed

  • 1.  Task Force on Maintaining a Fair and Impartial Judiciary Appointed

    Posted 03-10-2016 04:32 PM

    The Association’s House of Delegates voted to support the appointment of a task force to examine issues with the current judicial election process.  The task force was specifically asked to address the following issues:

    1. Whether Judges in Arkansas should continue to be elected or whether an appointment process would be more appropriate.

    2. If an appointment process is recommended, should it apply to all Judges or only Appellate Judges?

    3. If an appointment system is recommended, how should the appointment process be structured?

    4. Should some specific level of financial contribution to a Judge's campaign cause automatic recusal of that Judge regarding cases involving the contributor?

    5. What safeguards can be used in order to best protect the judicial election process from the influence of "dark money"?

    It is anticipated that the Task Force will present their recommendations to the House of Delegates at their June 18, 2016 meeting.  The Task Force members are listed below. 


    Jon Comstock, Chair

    Associate Dean Theresa Beiner
    Robert Cearley
    Bob Estes
    Judge David Guthrie
    Scott Hardin
    Paul Keith
    Professor Mark Killenbeck
    Marie-Bernarde Miller
    Brant Perkins
    Troy Price
    Brian Ratcliff
    Representative Matthew Shephard
    Judge Mary Spencer McGowan
    Justin Tate
    Guy Wade
    David H. Williams

    ------------------------------
    Eddie Walker Jr.
    Walker, Shock & Harp, PLLC
    Fort Smith AR
    479-783-5000
    ------------------------------